Both platforms excel at social media integration, but they serve different business models. Here’s how they compare specifically for selling through social channels.
Social Media Integration Comparison
Key Differences Breakdown
1. Number of Social Channels
Square Online:
-
Integrates with Facebook, Instagram, Google, and Pinterest
-
Syncs product catalog automatically to these platforms
-
Supports Facebook & Instagram ads directly from Square dashboard
Ecwid:
-
Integrates with Facebook, Instagram, Etsy, Amazon, eBay, and Google
-
More comprehensive marketplace coverage (Etsy, Amazon, eBay)
-
Better for businesses selling across multiple platforms
Winner: Ecwid (more channels, including major marketplaces)
2. Product Sharing & Posting
Square Online:
-
Basic social media integration
-
Can create Facebook & Google ads from dashboard
-
No built-in product sharing from mobile app
-
No scheduled posting automation
Ecwid:
-
Mobile app feature: Share product image + description directly to Instagram feed or Story from app
-
From admin: Share products to Facebook Page Timeline, Story, or Twitter directly from product editing page
-
Outfy app: Automatically share products to all social networks with scheduled posts
-
Social Boost app: Run contests, giveaways, and reward followers for sharing
Winner: Ecwid (significantly more sharing automation)
3. Multi-Channel Inventory Sync
Ecwid’s primary focus is multi-channel selling – it’s designed to be the central point managing all your sales channels.
Winner: Ecwid (centralized multi-channel management)
4. Social Media Marketing Tools
Square Online:
-
Built-in Facebook & Google Ads creation
-
Vouchers and email marketing
-
Facebook Messenger integration
-
No contest/giveaway tools
Ecwid:
-
Outfy app: Automated social posting scheduler (creates posts, plans timing)
-
Social Boost app: Social media contests, giveaways, lotteries, raffles with reward pop-ups
-
Zotabox app: Social sharing buttons for Facebook, Twitter, Pinterest, Instagram, YouTube, etc.
-
Discount coupons for social promotions
Winner: Ecwid (more marketing automation and engagement tools)
5. Free Plan Social Selling
Important: Ecwid’s free plan (0 products) doesn’t include social media integrations. You need the Starter plan ($5/month) for 5 products + social selling.
Square Online’s free plan includes unlimited products and full Facebook/Instagram integration.
Winner: Square Online (social selling on free plan)
6. Payment Gateways for Social Sales
Square Online:
-
Square (primary)
-
Apple Pay
-
Google Pay
-
PayPal (on paid plans only)
-
Limited gateway selection
Ecwid:
-
Much larger selection: PayPal, Stripe, Worldpay, Square, Apple Pay (via Stripe), Authorize.net, 2Checkout
-
More control over payment options for social purchases
Winner: Ecwid (more payment flexibility)
Which Should You Choose for Social Media Selling?
Choose Square Online If:
-
✅ You want free social selling (no monthly fee)
-
✅ You already use Square POS for in-person sales
-
✅ You primarily sell on Facebook + Instagram only
-
✅ You want simple Facebook/Google ad creation
-
✅ You have many products (unlimited on free plan)
-
✅ You prefer all-in-one website + social store
Best For: Physical stores, restaurants, small businesses selling mainly on Facebook/Instagram who want free unlimited product listings
Choose Ecwid If:
-
✅ You sell on multiple platforms (Facebook, Instagram, Etsy, Amazon, eBay)
-
✅ You have an existing website (WordPress, Wix, etc.) and want to add social selling
-
✅ You need automated social posting (Outfy scheduler)
-
✅ You run social contests/giveaways (Social Boost app)
-
✅ You want more payment gateway options
-
✅ You have 5+ products and can afford $5/month Starter plan
Best For: Multi-channel sellers, online businesses with existing websites, sellers on Etsy/Amazon/eBay, social media marketers needing automation
Pricing for Social Selling Features
Note: Ecwid’s $5/month Starter plan is still much cheaper than Square Plus ($29), but only supports 5 products.
Final Verdict
For Pure Social Media Selling on a Budget: Square Online
-
Free unlimited products on Facebook/Instagram
-
No monthly fees
-
Great for physical stores using Square POS
For Multi-Channel Social + Marketplace Selling: Ecwid
-
More social channels (Etsy, Amazon, eBay)
-
Automated posting and contests
-
Central inventory management across all platforms
Overall Winner for Social Media: EcwidDespite requiring a $5/month Starter plan, Ecwid provides superior multi-channel integration, automation tools, and payment flexibility for serious social media sellers.
Overall Winner for Free Social Selling: Square OnlineIf budget is your primary concern and you only need Facebook/Instagram, Square’s free plan with unlimited products is unbeatable.